Skip to content

BlogLocal SEO

Who Does ChatGPT Recommend in Your Market? A 45-Minute Check for Agents

AI quick win #1: ask ChatGPT, Google and Copilot the questions your clients ask, three times each, and log who gets named and which sources back them up.

Ryan Rockwood · 6 min read

On this page
AI quick win #1: see who ChatGPT recommends in your market

The short version: before you change anything, find out what AI already says. Ask ChatGPT, Google and Copilot the questions your buyers and sellers ask, three times each, and write down who gets named and which links back them up. That list tells you which of the other nine quick wins to do first.

  • Five questions, your town in each one, three runs per question.
  • Log names and sources. The sources are the useful part.
  • Judge by counts across runs. One answer means very little.
  • Time: about 45 minutes. Repeat every four to eight weeks.

“Why does ChatGPT recommend that agent and not me?” is the question we hear most right now. Close behind: “Can I even see what it says about me?” and “How would I know if anything I do changes it?” This is quick win #1 of 10, and it answers all three, because it’s the check you’ll use for every other win.

Why this matters

A buyer who types “who’s a good real estate agent in Westerville?” into ChatGPT usually gets a short written answer: three to five names, a sentence on each, and a few links. It’s not ten blue links anymore. The links show which pages the AI read and trusted.

OpenAI is open about how little it promises here. Its help center says ChatGPT may search the web on its own when a question needs current information, can use your approximate location, rewrites “near me” questions into searches with the city name, and ranks results “using multiple factors intended to help users find relevant, reliable information. Placement is not guaranteed.” It also says results and citations “can be incomplete, outdated, or incorrect” (OpenAI Help Center). Google says something similar about its AI features: AI Mode and AI Overviews “may use different models and techniques, so the set of responses and links they show will vary” (Google Search Central).

So there’s no secret ranking to reverse-engineer. What you can see is a pattern: which kinds of sources keep showing up for your market, and whether any of them mention you.

What we saw when we ran it

On November 16, 2026, we asked OpenAI’s search-enabled model twelve questions across Columbus, Tampa and Boise, three times each: 36 answers, each one fresh, with no account, memory or history.

  • Names moved a lot. 106 different agents or teams were named across the twelve questions. Only 4 appeared in all three runs of the same question. 79 appeared just once.
  • Profiles did a lot of the vouching. Of 242 cited links, 96 were portal, review or social profiles (Zillow alone was 46). Another 86 were other sites, mostly agents’ and teams’ own pages and local guides.
  • Public records showed up constantly. 29 of the 36 answers cited a state government real estate page, and 26 told the reader to verify the agent’s license.
  • Every answer said to interview agents, and 28 mentioned reviews.

Limits: one day, three markets, a small sample. The API with web search is close to, but not the same as, the ChatGPT app, which can add maps, business cards, memory and personalization. This shows what got cited, not what causes a mention, and it’s no promise that anyone gets named. We publish totals only, not the agents’ names.

The steps (about 45 minutes)

1. Write five real questions (5 minutes)

Use the words your clients use, with your town or area in each one. Mix one general question with specific ones:

  • “Who’s a good real estate agent in [town]?”
  • “Which realtor should I hire to sell my house in [town]?”
  • Three about what you actually do: first-time buyers, relocating from another state, condos, homes in a flood zone, an inherited house, new construction.

Keep them fair-housing safe: ask about goals, property types and situations, never about who lives somewhere.

2. Ask each one three times (20 minutes)

Use ChatGPT in a temporary chat, or signed out, so your own history doesn’t color the answer. Then ask each question once in Google (look at the AI Overview, or try AI Mode) and once in Copilot or Gemini. Different tools lean on different sources, and you want to see all of them.

3. Log names and sources (15 minutes)

Click the citations, or the Sources button when it appears. Copy this into a spreadsheet:

Date Tool Question Run Names given Sources cited (site and page type) Me? (named / cited / no)
Nov 16 ChatGPT Good agent in [town] 1 A, B, C zillow.com profile; state license lookup; agent B’s relocation page no
Nov 16 ChatGPT Good agent in [town] 2 B, D realtor.com profile; local association directory no

4. Read the pattern (5 minutes)

Count, don’t eyeball. Which sources show up in more than one run? Is it portal profiles, your state’s license page, the local REALTOR® association, a news story, or another agent’s page about that exact situation? Then look at the agents who keep getting named and what those sources say about them. If you’re named, check that the facts are right: brokerage, phone, areas, years licensed.

What the check usually points to

How can I check if it’s working?

The log is the check. Run the same five questions the same way every four to eight weeks, and compare how often you’re named or cited across all the runs. Don’t react to one answer, good or bad; in our test most names showed up only once.

Two free tools help on the search side. Bing Webmaster Tools has an AI Performance report that shows when your pages are cited in Copilot and Bing’s AI answers (Microsoft notes a citation isn’t a click or a ranking) (Bing Webmaster Tools). Google Search Console counts traffic from AI Overviews and AI Mode in its Performance report. And if you want to claim your business inside ChatGPT itself, our ChatGPT Business Hub guide covers it.

Want us to run it for you?

We run this check for members on the questions that matter in their market, keep the log over time, and turn what it shows into a short fix list. Most of the fixes live on your website, which is our day job. Ask us and we’ll show you what AI says about you today.

Ask us to check what AI says about you · Next: Quick win #2: make sure AI can read your site · All 10 quick wins

Sources

Filed underLocal SEOReal Estate Online Marketing